Kaiser Permanente’s Department of Research and Evaluation in Southern California is 1 of 42 health systems selected to participate in a PCORI initiative.
Kaiser Permanente study supports starting screening at age 45 among this higher-risk population
By Sue Rochman
A new study by researchers at Kaiser Permanente Northern California showed starting annual colorectal cancer screening at age 45 in African Americans can find colorectal cancers at a rate similar to that seen when screening starts after age 50 — the age most guidelines currently recommend.
“With data showing an increased incidence of colorectal cancer in African Americans at younger ages, guidelines have recommended this group start screening at age 45,” said study author Theodore R. Levin, MD, a research scientist at the Kaiser Permanente Northern California Division of Research and a gastroenterologist with The Permanente Medical Group. “But no one had actually tried to implement a screening program in this age group, so we didn’t know if it would work or have any value.”
To answer that question, in 2018 Dr. Levin and his colleagues evaluated the response rate to fecal immunochemical test (FIT) colorectal cancer screening in 10,232 African Americans ages 45 to 50 and the number of cancers detected. About one-third (3,390) of the patients returned the test; of these, 135 had a positive result. Among this group, 114 had a recommended colonoscopy, leading to 3 colorectal cancer diagnoses. The response rate and number of cancers diagnosed were similar to those seen in previously unscreened Kaiser Permanente Northern California members ages 51 to 56 who received a FIT test in 2018.
Colorectal cancer is the second leading cause of cancer deaths in the United States. The American Cancer Society estimates that this year 147,950 people will be diagnosed with —and 53,200 people will die from — colorectal cancer. But the disease does not affect all racial and ethnic groups equally. For example, from 2012 to 2016, colorectal cancer incidence rates in African Americans were about 20% higher than in whites and about 50% higher than in Asians and Pacific Islanders. Death rates in African Americans were almost 40% higher than in whites and double that seen in Asians and Pacific Islanders.
“There are no established reasons for these national demographic disparities,” said study author Douglas A. Corley, MD, PhD, MPH, a research scientist at the Division of Research and a gastroenterologist with The Permanente Medical Group. “Possibilities include differences in risk factors, such as diet, genetic predisposition, or use of health care. However, a study in California showed that health care can make a difference.
“It found no racial or ethnic differences in the risk of dying from colorectal cancer among people who were members of integrated health care systems, like Kaiser Permanente. But racial and ethnic differences were seen in people not in these types of health care systems. This strongly suggests that lower access to coordinated healthcare, including screening, may cause some of the differences seen nationally.”
Routine colorectal cancer screening reduces deaths through prevention — removal of precancerous polyps — and detection of easier-to-treat early-stage cancers. The United States Preventive Services Task Force recommends colorectal cancer screening start at age 50 for people who are at average risk and who do not have a family history of the disease. FIT screening is a stool-based test that can be done at home. Since 2008, Kaiser Permanente has mailed a FIT test kit annually to all members ages 51 to 75 who are not up-to-date on colorectal cancer screening; members return the test kit to a Kaiser Permanente laboratory in a postpaid envelope. Individuals who do not return the test within 4 weeks receive a call prompting them to do so; a reminder postcard is mailed to those who have not returned the test within 6 weeks.
“We had an existing mailed FIT screening program in place for about 11 years, so it was easy to plug this new screening program into that system,” said Dr. Levin. One key change, he said, was including new materials in the FIT kits for younger African Americans that explained why screening for colorectal cancer was specifically important for them.
The study findings led The Permanente Medical Group to begin sending annual FIT kits in 2019 to every African American member at age 45. “Finding 3 people with cancer so that they could get treated was very gratifying,” said Dr. Levin. “Studies aren’t just about data. There are real people who are affected by the choices we make about when to start screening.”
This study was funded by The Permanente Medical Group Delivery Science and Applied Research Program and the National Cancer Institute–funded Population-Based Research Optimizing Screening Through Personalized Regimens (PROSPR) consortium.
Co-authors include Christopher D. Jensen, PhD, MPH, Neetu M. Chawla, PhD, Lori C. Sakoda, PhD, MPH, Jeffrey K. Lee, MD, MAS, Wei K. Zhao, MPH, and Charles P. Quesenberry, PhD, of the Kaiser Permanente Northern California Division of Research; Molly A. Landau, MPH, Eryn Eby, MPH, and Ariel Herm, MPH of The Permanente Medical Group.
Sue Rochman is senior writer, Medical & Science Research, at the Kaiser Permanente Division of Research in Northern California. This is reprinted from the Division of Research.