The professional and personal perks of journal peer review

In an era where artificial intelligence promises to transform medicine, there is simply no substitute for a trained physician’s judgement and expertise in evaluating new research. That’s why so many busy clinicians choose to contribute as peer reviewers, strengthening their profession while benefiting personally and professionally.

At first glance, the work of practicing physicians and peer reviewers may not seem to have much in common. Physicians spend their days providing patient-centered care, coordinating with teams, and keeping up with the latest clinical guidelines, specialty association updates, and medical literature. But many clinicians also discover the benefits of medical journal peer review — work that may look very different from daily practice yet directly supports the science that guides it.

Related clinical research webinar: Webinar on medical research: AI, building trust, and JAMA’s vision

Peer review is quiet, often solitary, and voluntary. It comes without the direct pressures of clinical care. And yet, modern medical practice advances in large part because of the work of peer reviewers. Many are physicians themselves, lending their time and expertise to ensure the science guiding patient care is accurate, rigorous, and relevant.

The many benefits of peer review 

Although peer review can feel like a thankless job, clinicians who choose to perform peer reviews can experience a broad range of benefits, including:

• Boosting professional credibility. Adding peer review experience to a LinkedIn profile or curriculum vitae signals recognized expertise. After all, a journal editor wouldn’t select reviewers if they didn’t have the necessary knowledge or insights.

• Opening doors to leadership opportunities. Consistent, high-quality reviews can lead to invitations to serve on editorial boards — prestigious roles valued by hiring managers and promotion committees.

• Sharpening clinical and scientific edge. Reviewing manuscripts keeps judgment sharp, knowledge current, and the scientific method top of mind.

• Expanding professional networks. Providing timely and rigorous peer reviews is a great way to build relationships with editors and researchers, while gaining early access to emerging studies.

• Advancing the profession while finding purpose. By contributing to the advancement of science while supporting fellow researchers, reviewers not only strengthen the quality of research but also gain a deep sense of fulfillment and pride.

• Staying ahead of the latest research. Reviewers gain a front-row seat to cutting-edge studies before publication — and leave their mark by influencing what gets shared with the world.

Why peer review matters

Peer reviewers strengthen the backbone of science by building trust in research. For physicians, the impact extends beyond improving a paper or supporting fellow authors. Serving as a peer reviewer offers personal rewards as well as professional ones, but the ultimate reward is clear: an improved body of literature that advances medicine for everyone.

Becoming a reviewer

Want to become a peer reviewer? There are journals in nearly every specialty of medicine. Consider connecting with editors to discuss your goal of joining a peer review panel. You can also nominate yourself or a colleague to review for The Permanente Journal, which is always open to receiving new peer reviewers from all areas of medicine. Invitations to review are automated, so you can accept or decline as you see fit.